PTZ Tracker vs Canon RA-AT001: an honest comparison
My church was looking for a way to track our pastor on our Canon PTZ cameras, but there were no existing solutions that worked for us. We tried Canon's own tracker, the Auto Tracking Application RA-AT001, and found it to be the best at the time, so we made the $800 purchase for just one of our cameras since the license is per camera. Over the past months I was not satisfied with the lack of control we had over the tracking.
PTZ Tracker is our app. It runs natively on Mac, watches the camera's video over the network, and steers the camera from there. It costs $149 for one Mac, and that Mac can track as many cameras as it has the power for.
Where Canon's RA-AT001 is better
Nothing else to run. The tracking runs inside the camera. There is no computer to keep on during the service, no app to open, and nothing to break if the desk PC restarts. PTZ Tracker needs a Mac with Apple silicon on macOS 15 or later, open and connected the whole time you track.
It sees the picture first-hand. Canon's tracker works on the image inside the camera. PTZ Tracker gets the video over the network, a fraction of a second late, and has to allow for that delay (the Video delay setting). If that delay is set wrongly, the camera overshoots or hesitates, but this has not been an issue for us.
It keeps zooming as the speaker moves. Canon describes an Auto Zoom setting that keeps the person the same size in the frame as they walk towards or away from the camera. This is a feature that PTZ Tracker does not yet have.
It frames more than one person. The paid version adds Multi-Person Framing, which zooms to fit several people, such as a panel or an interview. Canon also lists framing that follows which way someone faces and whether they sit or stand. Canon ties some of these to particular camera models, so check yours. As of now, PTZ Tracker follows and frames only one person at a time.
It can ignore parts of the room. The paid version lets you exclude areas from automatic subject choice and limit the area the camera tracks in, so people walking down the aisle don't steal the shot. PTZ Tracker has no exclusion areas. It picks the person nearest the centre, or the one you click. Adding exclusion areas is on our roadmap.
It comes from Canon. Support comes from the company that made the camera.
Where PTZ Tracker is better
Price with more than one camera. At Canon's US price, three cameras need $2,400 of licences. PTZ Tracker is $149 for one Mac running all three, or $369 for three Macs. If you don't already have a Mac at the desk, add the price of one and you'll still be under Canon's price.
You choose how the camera moves. Pan and tilt each have a top speed (0.5 to 30 degrees a second), an inertia dial that sets how gently the camera starts and stops, and a responsiveness dial. Canon's paid version describes its control as tracking sensitivity on a scale from 1 to 10, and in our experience even the lowest setting was too fast and snappy and did not take advantage of the camera's capabilities.
A hold box that re-centres. PTZ Tracker's smart hold box keeps the camera still while the speaker gestures or shifts their weight. It collapses the moment the speaker steps outside it, allowing the camera to re-centre on the speaker, and grows back once they settle. The Canon tracker also has a hold box, but it is static, which means it does not grow or shrink, so the tracker stops the moment the speaker reaches the edge of the box, which leaves the camera off-centre.
Zones that call your camera presets. Draw a zone around the lectern or the piano. When the speaker has stayed in it for the dwell time you set, the camera moves to one of its own presets over 2 to 99 seconds, and cancels the move if they walk away. Canon's paid version has a fixed viewing angle area, which we found to be quite poorly designed: it is just a single angle and snaps to it the moment the speaker enters, which looks bad on a live broadcast.
Saved setups. PTZ Tracker has a highly customizable preset-saving system where you can save one camera's dials and zones as a named preset, or every camera's at once ("Sunday service", "Concert"), and bring them back with one click or one Stream Deck button. The Canon tracker has only saved settings 1 to 5, which are locked away.
Native API support. Tracking on and off, shot sizes, the speed dials, zones, saved setups, and camera presets each have a web address. You can then use Bitfocus Companion to put these controls easily onto a Stream Deck, or any other tool that can interact with HTTP.
Side by side
| RA-AT001 paid | PTZ Tracker | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $800 per camera (Canon USA) | $149 per Mac, any number of cameras |
| Runs on | The camera | A Mac with Apple silicon, macOS 15+ |
| Choosing who to follow | Automatic or manual | Automatic (most central) or click |
| Follows several people at once | Multi-Person Framing (check your model) | No, planned for the future |
| Keeps the person's size as they move | Auto Zoom | No; zooms once per shot size |
| Speed control | Sensitivity 1 to 10 | Top speed, inertia, and responsiveness per axis |
| Where the person sits in the frame | Anywhere | Anywhere; presets for rule of thirds |
| Ignore small movements | Pan/tilt halting area + simple hold box that does not adjust | Hold box with smart re-centring |
| Areas of the room | Priority, fixed angle, excluded, and limit areas | Preset zones with dwell and move time |
| Pan only | Yes | Yes, Freeze tilt |
| Free trial | 30 days | 14 days |
Which one to pick
Start with Canon's Lite tracker if it is already on your camera: it costs nothing and shows you what automatic tracking looks like in your room. Choose Canon's paid version if you film panels or interviews, need the zoom to follow the speaker, or don't want a computer in the chain. Choose PTZ Tracker if you run more than one camera, want the camera to move slowly enough for a livestream, or want zones that call your presets.
For costs and a setup walk-through for a church, see A Canon RA-AT001 alternative for churches.
PTZ Tracker's 14-day trial has every feature, so you can test it on your camera next to Lite before spending anything.